Monday, 21 October 2013

The glories of war and learning from history

Last month our television was put to rest. I was in favour of having it repaired, my wife decided that it needed replacing and consequently we now have a monstrosity that takes up most of the space on one side of the room. Despite our financial difficulties the 440 Euro needed to pay for this was translated into 24 monthly payments of 18 Euro plus a few cents and will disappear accordingly from her bank account.

Not sure whether Americans still use the "instalment plan" (see the Phil Spector produced Crystals' song "He's sure the boy I love" from the early 1960s - when the boy of her dreams has no money as could be seen by him buying on "the instalment plan"), or whether they simply stash the bill on their ever-increasing credit card debt. Buying by instalments seems more sensible, but anyway ....

Anyway this is now her new toy. Whether there is owt interesting on or not, it gets switched on and left on. Apart from wasting electricity, it is also an annoying source of noise when you are working on a translation. And particularly annoying when she heads off to the kitchen for half an hour and is obviously not watching it.

As was the case yesterday morning. Sunday. Germany. Mainstream channel ZDF. Summat that I had completely forgotten - religious broadcasts. There was this Lutheran pastor going on about his church's Catholic "Geschwister" - brothers and sisters. Nice word, nice thought.

So flip your mind back, as you are seditiously prone to do (particularly as a tolerant atheist), nearly 400 years to the start of the 30 Years War.

The 30 Years War was actually a series of wars rather than a continuous unbroken event. Its results were devastating. To quote the ever reliable Wikipedia (irony):

"A major consequence of the Thirty Years' War was the devastation of entire regions, denuded by the foraging armies. Famine and disease significantly decreased the population of the German states, Bohemia, the Low Countries and Italy; most of the combatant powers were bankrupted".

Great stuff, eh? Isn't war wonderful (extreme irony)? States getting bankrupted for the old political reasons rather than the new economic-political reasons. And no 17th century version of the Marshall Plan to bail out those involved either!

One of the fascinating things about this is that, if you bother to check out what historians inform you were the causes of the war, there is no one single reason for 30 years of wanton destruction. Events regarding the succession to the throne in Bohemia (today a significant part of the Czech Republic) eventually kick-started the whole series of events but the plot and counterplot elsewhere were far more significant than that.

That Protestants and Catholics chose to revive their rivalries upon a large scale should not be so surprising, given the times, but the relationships between the Catholic Bourbon dynasty in France and the Catholic Hapsburg dynasty in the Austrian dominated Holy Roman Empire and in Spain and in the "Southern Netherlands" (now Belgium) complicated the issue. Add to the fact that a bit of "Swedish imperialism" (yes, folks - Swedish imperialism!) was also a driving force.

By the end of the war Catholic France was the dominant power on the "Protestant" side, while Protestant Denmark was for some years fighting on the "Catholic"side, having previously fought for the "Protestant" side.

And eventually nobody really won. The towns of Munster and Osnabrück in Westfalen gained historical notoriety as the places where negotiations took place and eventually brought the whole sordid business to an end. After which Europe did not improve a great deal for several generations.

To bear in mind that at the time there was not even a semblance of anything democratic going on. The powers that existed were invested in not so benign monarchies - in many cases primitive dictatorships. The role of the common people was to serve their rulers and otherwise do as they were told. If you died in a war, if you died in a famine - same difference. Religion had a way of rearing its very ugly head, and may the proverbial non-existent Heaven save you if you embraced a Protestant (be it Lutheran or Calvinist) belief and the ruler of the state was a Catholic.

 To sit back and look at this now and think about Catholic "Geschwister" - we have come a long way. To think that continental Europe (outside of the Balkans) has managed nearly 70 years without a significant war ..... We have definitely come a long way.

To a point we have learned from history. Where economics are concerned we are backsliding considerably (and the return of rampant poverty, particularly among the elderly, must not be ignored), but the lot of the common people, which improved massively in the first 25 years following the Second World War, still is not as bad as in the 17th century.

Not that the craving for war has disappeared among small elements of the populations at large. And the need for extravagant "defence" ("offence"????) spending for such remains part of the platform of many principally (but not exclusively) conservative parties across the continent. If the UKIP/EXP ever gains power in the UK, they want four more nuclear weapons (check their manifesto - it is in there!). You wonder quite why. If the idea of a nuclear weapon is to frighten off potential attacks, why is one not enough, what do you need with all the others - unless your purpose is aggressive???? "We hate the EU, so let's nuke Brussels! And Berlin and Paris and Vienna and Warsaw and Riga and Ljubljana and Tallinn and ..... " (starts to salivate madly at the thought). Potentially dangerous people.

So maybe another war on the European continent is not so unlikely? Probably not - the old powers have moved on, merged, democratised, or simply faded into non-belligerent successful economic states (check Austria). It is a bit harder though for some than others (see France as well as the UK).

And who knows? The spirit of Gustavus Adolphus may suddenly re-emerge (check out some time the obscure town of Lützen in Saxony where he died in battle in 1632) and we may see a rise in Swedish imperialism again. Well I wouldn't bet your mortgage on it .....

No comments:

Post a Comment