Tuesday, 23 October 2012

So is style all that matters?

To my American liberal friends, please skip the next paragraph. For other American readers, please take note.

OK, I am a foreigner, I am not American, it is not my business - at least until your next financial crash (see 2008 when a "made in America" financial crash brought most of the European banking system down with it (although that didn't reach Spain finally till this year)). Or until your next unnecessary war when we are supposed (in order to keep you happy) to send some of bravest young people to die or get maimed in a conflict which is otherwise of little strategic interest to us. If Israel and Iran want to have a go at each other, why is that our business? And frankly I think that the threat from Iran is overrated anyway. Unlike Israel they have no history of starting wars - at least not for the past 200 years.

Everyone back? Right.

I was reading odd things this morning about the 3rd of the Presidential debates, last night in Florida. Most neutral sources were informing me that in the post-debate polls, Obama had won and won clearly. And unlike in the second debate there was no question of the moderator being allegedly biased.

I went on to YouTube and picked out a snippet from the American network ABC (part of the "liberal biased" media, if I remember rightly, or at least I have been so informed) upon who came out ahead after the "match". According to their political commentator, the answer was Romney, because despite everything he "looked Presidential".

Really. No arguments in his favour, no issues where he impressed, no world-shattering pieces of knowledge emanated from him (in fact the fact that Russia is an enemy to be feared is a shock to most of us here in Europe, and we are far closer to the action where they are concerned).

No substance, only style. Even the debate that he allegedly won it was pretty much that. Apparently within 24 hours after the end of the first debate, he had retracted the best part of half of what he had said. Most of the message seems to be "look at me, trust me, and wait till after you have elected me before I tell you what I am going to do". 

And 49% of potential American voters are happy to go along with that?

Well you don't like Obama, so Romney is bound to be better?

WRONG!

Obama may not be that good, Romney might be even worse, in fact very likely will be. You don't like unemployment at 8%, how does unemployment at 11% or 12% sound? You do not like a debt of 16 trillion Dollars, what does a debt of 19 trillion Dollars sound like (toss in Romney's tax cuts and massive increase in (unnecessary) defence spending, that is where the US national debt is heading with Romney in charge). 

You haven't got a very good choice (Jill Stein and Gary Johnson would be a more interesting contest), but given the crisis that you survived in 2008 what should you expect? There is optimism, and at the same time there is living in denial, and unfortunately the latter is more the case here than the former!

I was sitting in the doctor's surgery this afternoon reading the relatively conservative German weekly magazine "Focus". In it two German economists (one "liberal", one "conservative") looked at the US economy and reached the same conclusion. For the US debt to be cut, spending has to be cut (including the bloated defence budget), and taxes (no specification where incidentally) have to be raised!

Arithmetic!

With Obama and Romney, you will get neither. The balance though is, from any neutral perspective, in Obama's favour. Most of Romney's "savings" are minimal and based upon a lot of wishful thinking. And despite the noises last night the chances are that Obama is less likely to get involved in a war with Iran, which will be enormously expensive.

It is not totally an American problem, this matter of style. I was also reading in "Focus", a comment on the SDP choice for Chancellor to run against Merkel next year. For me the best candidate (of the three available - Steinbrück and Steinmeier were the others) would have been Sigmar Gabriel - he seems to realise more what "ordinary people" are going through better than the other choices available. Somehow though he is considered "unelectable"! Being concerned about the issues obviously makes less impact than the suit that you are wearing and the platitudes that you are uttering.

Wherever you are!

No comments:

Post a Comment