Saturday, 1 September 2012

Moral Compass - Part 2

The last time that I paid to go to a cinema to watch a film was as long ago as 1999.

The movie in question was "Analyze This" with Robert deNiro playing a Mafia don consulting a psychiatrist played by Billy Crystal (American spelling of "Analyze" incidentally as this was the film's name - I am not abandoning my use of UK English).  Amusing and well acted.

I used to go the cinema a lot when I was younger. These days I feel no need. I have bought DVDs of some movies I wanted to see, but the medium no longer appeals much.

I noted walking round Frankfurt the other day that there is a new Woody Allen movie out ("To Rome with Love"). This is getting good reviews and once upon a time I might have been tempted to go. I saw "Manhattan" and "Annie Hall" for example and enjoyed both.

There is though no way I will make any attempt to see this in any way, shape or form - as I refuse point blank to have anything to do with anything involving Woody Allen.

The reasoning is obvious.

There are simply no-go areas with relationships as far as I am concerned. I have written time and again about teachers and I will defend most of them almost to my last breath in just about every regard (I repeat for the umpteenth time, try putting yourself in front of a class of 15-year-old misfits some time!), but in no case will I defend anyone who crosses the line and gets intimate with one of their charges - reread the piece that I previously wrote on here.

Other obvious no-go areas? Parents sexually molesting their own children (I read a disturbing stat on how common that allegedly was in the UK a few years ago, I hope that the report was wrong!). That of course is illegal.

Then there are the grey areas. Step-parents getting involved with the their stepchildren, adoptive parents getting involved with their adopted children, foster parents with their foster children. I accept and acknowledge that when the "child" has reached the age of 18, he/she is now an adult and that there is no blood relationship between the parties concerned, but it is nonetheless IMHO a massive betrayal of trust.

The child may not be your physical child, but from every other perspective he/she is your child. You have assumed responsibility in loco parentis.  And that status should remain even when they have become adults. Changing them from your child to your partner is treading in very murky waters (apart from also being a betrayal of your partner for one of your "children"). I find this simply unacceptable.

It is legal? I believe so, although if someone changed the law to make it illegal, I for one would not object. Is it immoral? Define "immoral" for me, please. I will stay with "unacceptable".

It is difficult enough anyway to get suitable people to adopt or foster children as it is. Assume that a couple decides to adopt or foster a 13-year-old girl, how many extra checks do you have to make to ensure that her new "father" will not in five years time be looking to seduce her?

As for running off with them when they get to adulthood, this can be for one reason and one reason alone, which does not say anything positive about your behaviour or intentions. As a foster or adoptive parent you can see your now adult foster or adoptive child like blood related parents and adult children see each other - so why run off with them?

Well they are really in love, and good luck to them? Well if you want to believe that .... but it still does not change the (adoptive/foster) parent-child relationship in my book. The betrayal of trust factor is not changed, an adult has taken unnecessary advantage of a situation which should not be allowed to occur.

Which brings me back to Woody Allen and Mia Farrow's foster daughter, a double betrayal of trust, and a sense that I cannot accept the events the way that they occurred, nor can I allow the example that it set to remain without comment.

This cannot though be an indication of me having a moral compass, can it? After all, I am still an atheist!

No comments:

Post a Comment