There seems to be by the day an attempt on YouTube to silence any atheist voices - particularly noticeable is the abject cowardice of the people who administer what is allowed on the site in the face of the usual ignorant believers in the Muslim world.
One criticism of all the Islamic nonsense, or any of it for that matter, and zap! Your video is removed from the site. Well as all religions are founded upon ignorance, fear and superstition, and there is no religion that is more into ignorance, fear and superstition than Islam - particularly the fear factor, so maybe YouTube Admin can hear the stealthy feet of a suicide bomber hustling along the corridor outside, accompanied by some whispering of "Allah Akbar".
Meanwhile on the concept of the use of fear in the Islamic world, check out the recent case of the journalist, Hamza Kashgari, who faces possible execution in his home country of Saudi Arabia for making unacceptable (but pretty harmless if you actually read them!) comments on Twitter about the prophet Mahomet. No denying the existence of the non-existent Allah or anything else even. How do you spell "police state"? And how do you spell "Islamofascist"????
And then back in the Christian heartlands, there is one Dr. William Lane Craig who is a professed Christian philosopher and critic of atheists generally (in his favour, he is not advocating beheading them all yet, at least I think so).
One of his condescending comments on YouTube runs as follows:
Dr. William Lane Craig says it as it is when it comes to the Youtube world of atheists. Typical atheists on YouTube love to portray themselves as great intellectuals, but haven't studied philosophy, New Testament history, or theology.
Maybe then I am not a typical atheist. I am an intellectual. Not a "great" intellectual, just an intellectual. I am not a latter-day Bertrand Russell or Einstein or .... Well, you get the idea.
I have though studied philosophy (and I can tell the difference between thought and reasoning on the one hand, and dogma on the other, and religion, particularly organised religion, is more to do with the latter than the former!). I often talk to Buddhist monks about the world and how they see it. The philosophy of the Buddha is well worth considering, though its practical use depends upon others following the same path. Unfortunately it would not go down well in Saudi Arabia - see above!
I haven't studied New Testament history? I was a committed Christian until my scientific enlightenment at the age of 17, can quote large chunks of Saint Matthew's Gospel to this day, and I am well aware of how Christianity spread across Europe. Eventually the decision to abandon Norse mythology for Jewish revisionist mythology was a political decision rather than anything much to do with whether the latter was correct in its teachings.
And while we are on this topic, there are plenty of excellent YouTube videos explaining how the Bible was put together, what was included, what was not, and why there are so many inconsistencies running through it. Doctor Craig might be advised to check some of that material before condescending to condemn all atheistic YouTube input.
I haven't studied theology? See above. What I have seen and heard of Islam, it is probably as well I have not found out more about it. To be repeated though is what I have said on this blog enough times - all religions are stuck in their period. All were produced when much of what we now know was unknown, and most of the developments that we have experienced over 1500 to 3000 years would seem miraculous to the people who produced these myths for common consumption.
Perhaps the most telling point though is what I wrote in my last piece on this blog - namely to accept the existence of "God" would be "to allow for the existence of an undetectable, untraceable, unlocatable, invisible, untouchable, unhearable (unless you're a politician), unsmellable (if the word exists) being".
You can study all the history, all the "holy books", all the works on philosophy you like, you cannot get past this fact. Frankly until you, Doctor Craig, or whoever can make a realistic argument proving the existence of such an impossibility, all other research on the subject is meaningless.
Oh - and the title of this piece? To comment upon Doctor Craig's YouTube criticism you cannot do it on YouTube, you have to do it on his site on his turf (a forum). Sorry but I will not try to condense my reasoning into short pithy sentences on a forum - the arguments need far more space. I will at the risk of being a lone voice in the wilderness make my rational, intellectually-based arguments here - where I have the proverbial room to breathe.
No comments:
Post a Comment