Sunday, 13 November 2011

Iraq War Mark 2 - or what to expect from a US Republican President in 2013

Author's note (December 5th, 2021). This may no longer seem relevant and I considered deleting it. But some of the content still applies to the reasons for any invasion even now and the logic about the potential problems on the ground if an invasion did ever take place is absolutely relevant. And as for the comment about Israel - not so noticeable when the Democrats are in power, maybe, but .... Meanwhile I remain as neutral as ever about the Middle East. A two secular (moderate) state solution is what is needed. Given the Israeli hawks on the one hand and The Hamas extremists' influence on a large number of the Palestinians on the other .... no, I won't side with either of them. 

From yesterday's debate of US Republican Presidential candidates:

Gingrich quickly agreed with Romney, saying that if all other steps failed, "you have to take whatever steps are necessary" to prevent the Islamic regime from gaining a nuclear weapon".

Apart from this rhetoric sounding exactly like what we heard from Bush and company before the now discredited invasion of Iraq, has anybody worked out what this involves? Try the following:

1. Another instance of the United States Conservative establishment wishing to start an unnecessary war to satisfy its own agenda.
2. Invading a country that is three times the size of Iraq, has three times the population, and is far less ethnically divided than Iraq (it is a fundamentalist Shia Islamic state with only small Sunni and Kurdish populations).
3. If David Petraeus's estimates upon a required invasion force required for any successful invasion are correct, this will need something in the region of 2 to 3 million troops. This will almost certainly mean that the US will have to reintroduce conscription.
4. There will not be much by way of allied support - even the UK will be lukewarm (though it depends how poodle-like the leadership in London is before they provide the support - expect it to happen, do not expect guts from a British government on issues like this).
5. Iran is a divided country, the government is not popular. There is nothing like a foreign invasion (which is exactly what this will be) to unite a people.
6. In Iraq there were 2 million refugees as a result of the invasion. Are there plans to deal with the 6 million Iranian refugees resulting from this? Or does that not matter?

Also to bear in mind:
If Iran does have a nuclear weapon (not guaranteed), which they can fire accurately (even less guaranteed), do they have the technology to launch it some 10,000 miles so it will land anywhere near the United States? Answer - absolutely not!

So what is the justification for this? The Israeli tail waving the American dog? Again????

The answer to that should be - if the Israelis have a problem, let them sort it out for themselves! If they wish to invade Iran, let them get on with it!

But it certainly should not be the business of anyone in the West to resume the playing of the ridiculous script that was first played out in 2003.

There are US Republican candidates like Ron Paul, and commentators like Pat Buchanan, who are intelligent enough to realise this. The rest are not, and in my book are dangerous people who are not intelligent enough to deserve to be elected!

No comments:

Post a Comment