Monday, 26 September 2011

21 and past it, or when money is not enough

It is a story with international ramifications, though probably only people in Germany and Brazil will take notice.

In the past week the German media has been full of the story of Breno, a Brazilian football (soccer, if you must) player on the books of Bayern München.

He has been referred to in the media as Bayern "Star", Breno, but he is hardly that. He could have been a star player, he might still have become one, but in fact he is what he has been all his time here - a reserve player with unfulfilled potential.

He arrived for a massive sum of money at the age of 18, with the reputation already of a player with immense skill, and in the right organisation, who knows what he might become.

The problems of bringing in someone scarcely past adolescence who speaks not a word of the language are all too clear. And the problems also of having a reputation and having also to compete for playing time with older players who know the culture, only served to make things worse.

In three years he has hardly had a regular place ever, and has played rarely. Too expensive to play in the reserve team (which is fundamentally amateur), the frustrations of not getting a game grew to be enormous. Which was exacerbated by a series of injuries that might eventually end his career prematurely.

One thing added to another (and in three years here he has never learned German, which means that there are enormous communication difficulties), finally he needed to have psychological treatment. Whether a Portuguese speaking specialist was available is an interesting question. Finally the fuse broke, and he set fire (allegedly - the case is still sub judice) to the 1 million + Euro valued villa he owned in Munich, destroying everything (including his passport) in the process.

Following which he is being held in jail, and will not be released until the full legal proceedings have been completed. He is apparently a "flight risk".

Now quite where a young man who only speaks Portuguese, who has no passport left and who would be well-enough known for the Brazilian Embassy for them to refuse to issue any replacement, would fly to is an interesting question.

Interesting though is the question - if he had been simply an 18-year-old immigrant with no money who had come to work on a building-site or in a hotel kitchen, would he have been allowed to spend three years here not learning the language, or developing psychological problems which would lead to an act of wanton vandalism?

He had money, he had people to help and support him, he had people who had faith in his ability - Bayern's top executives have issued a series of statements of support today, as have his team mates.

Something, somewhere does not ring true here - the inconsistencies running through the story open up a whole series of unanswered and seemingly unanswerable questions. The point remains though that while lack of money causes many people (including myself) to face challenges that seem impossible to surmount, possession of it in abundance still leaves substantial issues that are seemingly impossible to resolve.

No comments:

Post a Comment